All Reviews
john knipe
5 months agoI drive from Point Pleasant every day just to get their bagels.. Freekin delicious. I feel like I'm eating a bagel from New York City. Great sandwiches! And if you want, just a toasted bagel with butter. They have the best butter.!!
Felts
Edited 6 months agoQuaint place. Nice folks. Good bagels. The bacon on the bagel was awesome! Who's bacon was that a d where can I get some? Thanks, Mark
Chris Wismar
6 months agoSo the most disgusting thing happened this morning I walked in to bakin bagels in Ortley beach and the employee was sitting in a chair behind the glass counter picking his nose(yes right in front of me and he didn’t look up from his cell phone) Another employee took my order and then said nose picker got up and reached in the bagel bin and grabbed the bagel with his dirty finger that was just up his nose. Are you kidding me? So I said you’re not serving me that bagel your finger was just up your nose and he turned around and said to me it’s OK. Needless to say to say I left and will never go back there again.
Nicholas Gagliano
8 months agoOk I have to , smh its just not right on so many levels. Look at the reviews for this place. So I ordered Bagle T wit CC. And a soda . The lady behind counter I think was mad I came in and ordered somthing, I felt it and right away she was visible angry and didnt even say ok or just one min just a mean look the other guy was staring off to space literally whole time . Lol. Another patron walked in And asked for a coffee and she said no they dont have it . There was 2 rather big coffee machine all lit up and visibly 3 feet from them. Smh I wished I never went . So he leaves she gives me my bagle wrapped in Saran Wrap. Hahahah not even cut in half. And my soda was 4 months past expiration. OOOOOKKKKAAAAYYYYY!!!!!!! HAHAHHA........ bagle and a come 9.80 lmao I cant ...
Jeffrey Camporini
9 months ago3 sandwiches and all were terrible for different reasons. Pieces of plastic in one, thick cut and fatty roast beef on another, and provolone cheese that was smelly and not edible. Probably fine for bagels, but would not get sandwiches here.
Wil Marto
10 months agoBagels are great and sitting outside while the island wakes up is my happy place.
Emily A
10 months agoThere’s so many better bagels on the shore. These tasted unfresh, and nothing like a Jersey bagel. Also the toppings on the breakfast sandwich’s were very stingy and they weren’t cheap.
Doug Powell
7 years agoThis morning we had an everything bagel toasted with the garlic and herb cream cheese as well as a cinnamon raisin bagel with cinnamon walnut cream cheese. Both were fantastic. This location has some great outdoor seating and is less than 100 yards fro the walkover for the beach. Great place to visit any time of year. Bakin Bagels is a great spot to get your morning bagel, an amazing sandwich or a decent slice of pizza at the beach. There are actually a few of them near the beach.